יום חמישי, 23 במאי 2013

Elder of Ziyon Daily News

Elder of Ziyon Daily News

Link to Elder of Ziyon

Egypt pulls funding for dwindling Jewish community

Posted: 22 May 2013 11:00 PM PDT

An official in Egypt's Ministry of Social Affairs has stated that the small annual stipend that Egypt had been spending on the tiny Jewish community has been eliminated in the newest budget.

Suad Makki, head of the Central Department for Financial and Administrative Affairs, told a meeting of the Commission on Human Rights of the Shura Council that the Egyptian government had been paying some $14,000 to the Jewish community almost every year since 1988. After the death earlier this year of Carmen Weinstein, the head of the community, Makki says that there is no longer a liaison.

Egypt has an estimated 20 remaining Jews, all elderly women, according to the report.

Weinstein was officially succeeded by Magda Haroun, and it is unclear why she is not continuing Weinstein's role, or if the cash-strapped Egyptian government is using Weinstein's death as an excuse.

Arab review of Bibi's book: "As dangerous as Mein Kampf"

Posted: 22 May 2013 06:00 PM PDT

I am not sure why a Yemen newspaper decided to review Binyamin Netanyahu's 2000 book, A Durable Peace: Israel and its Place Among the Nations, but the review is most revealing.

The reviewer says that the book is filled with "lies and slander as well as hatred and contempt for all that is Arab."

This book does not less dangerous than the book Mein Kampf, Hitler's book, or The Jewish State by Herzl ...
Netanyahu in this book turns historical facts upside down and manipulates geography and history, using excerpts from the lies of the Zionists or scraps of papers of history or words amputated from the mouths of historians to give a historical and legal right in what he calls the Land of Israel to be a national home for the Jews.

He says that throughout 1200 years the Arabs only founded one city in Palestine, Ramle....

Netanyahu claims that Israel's wars with the Arabs were in self-defense and in line with Jewish ethics. 

This is a good reminder that Bibi's book is still a very good read.

See this somewhat related post from 2008.

Wednesday Links Part 2

Posted: 22 May 2013 03:30 PM PDT

From Ian:

Throw Away That Rusty Key
Palestinians are not "red indians" and Israelis are not colonialists. Quite the opposite. We Jews of the Middle East and North Africa are indigenous—predating Islam in Palestine, and the region, by 1,000 years. Israel is not only the "largest and most successful refugee camp" in the region, but the authentic expression of a native Middle Eastern people.
Both sets of refugees suffered, with one glaring difference: the Arab refugees—and those 10,000 Jews chased out of Jerusalem and "the West Bank" by the Jordanian Arab Legion—fled the horrors of war. But the Jews living in Arab countries were non-combatants, targeted as members of the "Jewish minority of Palestine."
Palestinian Fairytales
It is only really due to the persistence of Richard Landes and Phillipe Karsenty and a few others that fought tooth and nail that we are at the stage we are today, and that the Israeli Government has investigated and officially denounced the incident as fake.
Unfortunately, the damage is done, no matter what court rulings prove that the images were faked, the al-Dura image is forever etched in people's minds, and to this day is still used in the Arab world to incite violence, and will continue to be.
Fisking Rachel Shabi: How Dare the Israelis Suggest Palestinians Lied!
There is perhaps no society on earth with as dark a history of promoting a child death cult, sacrificing its children, encouraging its children to seek death, praising those who die, than the Palestinians. Any serious investigation here will not go well for the Palestinians, who systematically, indeed ghoulishly exploit the children whose deaths they cause.
Israel's UN envoy: Palestinian 'hatred' threatens talks
Israel's Ambassador to the United Nations, Ron Prosor, accused Saeb Erekat, the Palestinian Authority's chief negotiator, of lies and incitement, after Erekat said Israel's policies were worse than those of apartheid-era South Africa.
"Saeb Erekat never misses an opportunity to lash out at Israel on the international stage," Prosor said Monday. "One would expect that a man in charge of peace negotiations would instill peace, not incitement."
Jewish Group Blasts 'Electro-Intifada' for Sports Boycott Calls
"The ideological forebearers of today's racists, in Nazi Germany had 'ethnically cleansed' sports, as blatantly demonstrated in the 1936 Berlin Olympics."
"Jews especially, were the object of boycott as Hitler Youth stormed their stores to the screams of 'Kaufen nicht bei Juden' (Buy not from Jews)! Anti-Jewish boycott has now returned, in the guise of the so-called 'B.D.S.' (Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions) campaign to delegitimize the State of Israel," it continued.
Google inflames Gush Etzion residents by situating them in 'Palestine'
Resident of Gush Etzion settlement calls Google's apparent decision to redirect its areas' web users to Palestinian handle "simply outrageous" • Rights group: It's unfortunate Google says Judea and Samaria residents belong to the Palestinian Authority.
Meg Ryan's Publicist: Ryan Didn't Boycott Israel
But in an email to CAMERA, Stephen Huvane, a founder of Slate PR and Meg Ryan's publicist, said "That report is untrue. Meg Ryan never participated in any boycott against Israel." In a follow up email, CAMERA asked Mr. Huvane: "Had she scheduled a 2010 trip to Israel to participate in the Jerusalem Film Festival? If so, what was the cause for the cancellation?"
Detroit Leaders Should Have Spurned, Not Embraced, Farrakhan
During his speech to the congregation at The Fellowship Chapel in Detroit, Farrakhan spewed hateful anti-Semitic invective, referring to "Satanic Jews" and the "Synagogue of Satan" supposedly controlling major institutions. He expressed his love for President Barack Obama, but added that the president "surrounded himself with Satan...members of the Jewish community."
Belgian party leader stepping down 'temporarily' over slur
The leader of a small Belgian party said she would "temporarily step down" after stating that "a few Jewish families that monopolize the banking world" caused the financial crisis in Europe.
Alleged NJ synagogue bombers plead not guilty
Two New Jersey men accused of firebombing several synagogues in the state pleaded not guilty.
Anthony Graziano of Lodi and Aakash Dalal of New Brunswick, both 21, made their pleas on Monday in state Superior Court in Hackensack, The Record reported.
A 'watch' that stops unnecessary heart attack deaths
About half of all people at risk of death from heart attacks could gain the chance to live, once Israeli entrepreneur Leon Eisen's new Oxitone device goes to market in about 18 months.
Using two optical sensors, and another special high-tech tool, he's developed the world's first "watch" that can just about tell when your time may be up.
Brazil 2014 Fifa World Cup to be Protected by US Robots and Israeli Drones
Brazilian police will be equipped with advanced facial recognition camera glasses which will enable them to capture 400 images per second.
Brazil has also ordered several Israeli-made drones costing nearly $25m and German-manufactured anti-aircraft tanks.
Exhibit opens on US Jews who helped refugees from Nazis
'An exhibition opens Tuesday at a museum in Lower Manhattan about efforts by American Jews to bring refugees to the US from Europe during the Nazi era.
The exhibition, "Against All Odds: American Jews and the Rescue of Europe's Refugees, 1933-41″ will be on view for a year at the Museum of Jewish Heritage — A Living Memorial to the Holocaust, located on Battery Place.
Comedy for Koby Returns for Tenth Run
Proceeds from Comedy for Koby benefit The Koby Mandell Foundation, an organization founded in memory of Koby Mandell, a young teenager who was killed by terrorists while hiking with his friend, Yosef Ishran, near his home in 2001.
The two friends had gone for a walk in Wadi Tekoa. Terrorists bound the boys and beat them to death with stones.

Turkish Armenian sentenced to jail for blasphemy - for anti-hate speech article

Posted: 22 May 2013 01:40 PM PDT

From Hurriyet Daily News:

An Istanbul court has sentenced Turkish-Armenian writer Sevan Nişanyan to 58 weeks in prison for an alleged insult to the Prophet Muhammad in a blog post.

The prosecutor had been seeking one and a half years of jail time for Nişanyan on charges of "insulting the religious beliefs held by a section of the society."

The sentence cannot be converted to a financial penalty, but Nişanyan has the right to appeal.

He was charged with blasphemy after writing a blog post titled, "[We] need to fight hate speech."

"Making fun of an Arab leader who claimed he contacted Allah hundreds of years ago and received political, financial and sexual benefits is not hate speech," Nişanyan said in his post last year. "It is an almost kindergarten-level test of what is called freedom of expression."

On May 22, the day of the sentencing, Nişanyan retweeted his blog post, writing, "Let's share the article that was sentenced to 13-and-a-half months at the Istanbul 10th Criminal Court for insulting religious bla-bla."
Yes, in Turkey, defending free speech can be a hate crime.

In his original blog post that got him in trouble Nişanyan also called out Muslim Jew-hatred, saying that Muslim preachers who say that the tiny number of Jews in the world are part of an "abhorrent race" and behind all the evils in the world are "vomiting nonsense" and this is a classic example of a hate crime.

You wouldn't know that by reading the websites of Amnesty and Human Rights Watch.

(h/t Gidon Shaviv)


HRW official and journalists call IDF liars in private Facebook group

Posted: 22 May 2013 12:05 PM PDT

From The Washington Free Beacon:
A "secret" Facebook group of foreign correspondents and human rights activists quickly devolved into an anti-Israel hate-fest on Tuesday following the release of a new Israeli government report that cleared the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) of wrongdoing in the 2000 death of a Palestinian boy.

The Israeli government report contests the claim that the IDF killed a Palestinian boy, Muhammad al-Durrah, in a famous 2000 incident in Gaza that helped ignite the Second Intifada.

Journalists and activists mocked the report, attacked the IDF, and claimed pro-Israel lobbyists were influencing the media coverage, in a private Facebook group for foreign correspondents known as the "Vulture Club."

Peter Bouckaert, a senior official at Human Rights Watch, dismissed the report as "typical IDF lies."

"As usual, it takes them a long time to really build up the falsehood," wrote Bouckaert.

Bouckaert also blasted the New York Times for its coverage of the report.

"It really isn't good journalism to write this up as if these are credible allegations when it is a pack of lies," he wrote.

Correspondents from numerous outlets, including the Associated Press and the Agence France-Presse, also piled on.

"[T]he lobby uses all its strength and is able to push anything in majors [sic] English newspapers or in the NYT[imes]," wrote El Mundo reporter Javier Espinosa. "Israeli embassies call their contacts in all those newspapers and they agree to publish that information."

"That reinforces lack of media credibility and conspiracy theories as we are being used as mouthpieces for propaganda," Espinosa added.

Associated Press photojournalist Jerome Delay wrote, "The IDF thinks the earth is flat, btw."
So the anti-Israel media and "human rights" officials get all chummy and reinforce each others' lies, and they say that the IDF controls the media?

(h/t Noah)

The New Antisemitism (Israel Channel 2)

Posted: 22 May 2013 11:10 AM PDT

This video has been released with English subtitles:




The Keshet documentary is a Canadian-Israeli co-production presented by Israeli anchorman Ya'akov Eilon. The binational cooperation enabled Canadian journalists to interview people that Israelis would not have had access to, such as Alex Linder, the owner and operator of the viciously anti-Semitic, white supremacist Vanguard News Network.

The filmmakers document what they describe as "new Anti-Semitism" through the use of hidden cameras in conferences, demonstrations and behind the scenes of anti-Zionist meetings across the globe.

Filmmaker and director Martin Himel told The Jerusalem Post that the primary objective of the documentary is to present "Anti-Semitism in action," to allow viewers to feel what it means and to acknowledge that is exists.

"My goal was not so much to explain it [Anti-Semitism] or to describe how people suffer. For me it was more important to say, 'Here is the new Anti-Semitism, take a look and see it for what it is,'" he clarified.

The director pointed to comparisons of Jews with Nazis and the use of terms such as "genocide," "extinction" and extermination" when discussing Israel as examples of contemporary Anti-Semitism. He also cited claims that Jews control Hollywood, the banks and the media as examples.

He was keen, however, to point out the difference between being critical of Israel and being anti-Semitic, saying that the former conversely includes language such as "occupation," "annexation of territories" and "settlements." Himel also flagged lobbies such as Occupy AIPAC, which he charged with disguising Anti-Semitism with anti-Zionism. The documentary "pulls the pants down on people who say 'I'm anti- Zionist, not an anti-Semite,'" Himel told the Post.

(h/t Yoel)

Wednesday Links Part 1

Posted: 22 May 2013 09:00 AM PDT

From Ian:

Inconceivable cruelty
This division in the Arab world, be it geographic, cultural, ethnic or religious, is not the only thing to become abundantly clear since the Arab unrest erupted. The Arab Spring was supposed to prove that what is good for the West -- democracy -- is also good for the Arabs, but all we were left with were the chilling images of our neighbors' inconceivable cruelty. (h/t Yoel)
IDF chief issues stern warning to Assad over rapidly heating border
Damascus will 'bear consequences' of further gunfire, says Gantz, after cross-border shooting; tensions 'several times more explosive than they were this morning,' says top Israeli analyst
Palestinians busted for planning to kidnap Israelis
According to the Shin Bet's statement, they planned on kidnapping an Israeli from one of the nearby agricultural plots, with the intention of murdering him and demanding the release of prisoners in return for his body.
A second cell was organized by the Islamic Jihad in Hebron. Its members were in the process of plotting to abduct a soldier and negotiate his release in return for Palestinians in Israeli jails.
'11 Palestinians died under PA, Hamas detention' By Khaled Abu Toameh
Eleven Palestinians have died in Palestinian Authority and Hamas detention centers during 2012, according to a report released Tuesday by the Palestinian Independent Commission For Human Rights.
Two of the Palestinians died in PA detention centers in the West Bank, while the nine others died in Hamas custody in the Gaza Strip.
The Palestinian Textbook Fiasco
"What I found isn't pretty. The report is not only flawed, but also dishonest. It systematically exaggerates the faults in Israeli textbooks and downplays those found in the Palestinians'. Its methodology tends to distort the raw data rather than analyze it, usually to the detriment of the Israeli education system. Put simply, it makes every possible effort to create the impression that Israeli and Palestinian attitudes toward each other are the same, even when this is demonstrably untrue—according to the study's own research data. It is no surprise that the State Department, which funded the study in its early phases, has endorsed neither the composition of the committee nor the report's findings."(h/t Yerushalimey)
Hamas textbooks to teach about 'liberation plans' By Khaled Abu Toameh
Hamas has begun preparing new school textbooks that teach children about "plans to liberate Palestine and the legitimacy and various forms of resistance [against Israel]." Jamal Abu Hashem, advisor to the Hamas-controlled education ministry, said new books would be introduced as part of National Education Studies for grades 8-10.
Abu Hashem was speaking during a workshop in Gaza City that was attended by senior officials of the education ministry and experts from a number of universities. His statements were published by several Hamas websites.
Gaza Students: Clean the World of Jews
Hamas student group posts cartoon with 'Palestine' throwing Star of David in the trash.
The Hamas-affiliated student union in Gaza published a cartoon Tuesday in which a person whose body is made of a Palestinian Authority flag is seen throwing a Star of David – one of the best-known Jewish symbols – into a garbage can.
Text under the picture says, "Keep the world clean."
Move over Galloway: BBC Radio Ulster airs pro-Assad & anti-Israel propaganda
The programme's guest who was provided with a BBC platform from which to engage in that diatribe was prolific anti-Israel campaigner, Vanunu fan, 'Global March to Jerusalem' supporter, 'Russell Tribunal on Palestine' "jury" member and former flotilla passenger Mairead Maguire. Host William Crawley – apparently rather over-awed by her status as a 1976 Nobel Peace Prize winner – refrained from informing listeners about Maguire's rich history of anti-Israel activity before allowing her to launch into her largely unhindered propaganda rant.
CAMERA: Official PA daily acknowledges Israel's Hadassah hospital's treatment of Palestinians
The official PA daily reported on a visit by the PA Minister of Health, Hani Abdeen, to Israel's Hadassah Hospital in Jerusalem. The daily noted that 30% of the child patients in Hadassah are Palestinians and that the Israeli hospital is training "60 Palestinian medical interns and specialist physicians who will be returning to the [Palestinian] Authority areas to carry out their work." The hospital has a special program to train Palestinian doctors to treat cancer among children, reported the PA daily.
PMW: PMW reports prompt debate in Danish Parliament about its funding of the PA
Following Palestinian Media Watch's exposure of the Palestinian Authority's glorification of terrorists and payment of high salaries to security prisoners, including terrorists convicted of murder, debates have ensued in European Parliaments, among them Norway, the UK and Holland. Now, Denmark's financial aid to the PA is likewise being questioned in Danish Parliament.
Seven security men kidnapped in Sinai freed
Six Egyptian policemen and a border guard kidnapped by suspected militants in the volatile Sinai Peninsula last week were freed by their captors Wednesday after successful mediation, the country's military spokesman said.
Hamas shuts tunnels to keep kidnappers from sneaking in
Hamas placed its forces along the border with Egypt on high alert Tuesday, in a bid to prevent the smuggling of seven abducted Egyptian soldiers into Gaza.
Barry Rubin: Breaking News: It's Official, Iran's Presidential Election is A Sham
The core of the problem is that there are three factions. Khamenei doesn't want two of the factions-- the super-hardliners and the reformists—to win but only the third group, his hardliners.
The super-hardline faction's candidate was Esfandiar Rahim Mashaei, Ahmadinejad's son-in-law and man widely seen as a puppet for him. Khamenei hates Mashaei and Mashaei was disqualified.
MEMRI: British Islamist Anjem Choudary: We Reject Human Rights


Leaders, Lies and Terror
The Obama Administration's acts surpass even the maneuvers by President Richard Nixon, who used spies against political opponents while covering up for Arab terror.
Nixon and Co. hid the fact that Yasser Arafat ordered the murder of three diplomats at the US embassy in Khartoum Sudan in January, 1974. The US concealed this for years, hoping Arafat would help the US and its intelligence services.
John Kerry Met With Father of 'Martyr' Killed During Mavi Marmara Ambush on Israeli Troops
In April, Kerry drew criticism for comparing the families mourning their loved ones killed in the Boston Marathon bombing with the families of those killed on the Mavi Marmara after those aboard the boat attempted to lynch IDF troops who boarded their vessel for a routine inspection. Seven of those aboard the Mavi Marmara had expressed a desire to become "martyrs."

SUV filled with missiles explodes in Sinai, killing driver

Posted: 22 May 2013 07:38 AM PDT

Al Ahram reports that a SUV loaded with missiles south of Rafah, near the border with Israel and Gaza, exploded yesterday.

Apparently, a rocket inside the car ignited and caused a spectacular explosion, ripping the driver's body to shreds, according to the report.

It is unclear whether these missiles were meant for Gaza terror groups or Sinai jihadists. Not that there is much of a difference.

Some work accidents are better than others.

Hamas security told to uphold "standards of manliness"

Posted: 22 May 2013 06:00 AM PDT

Great stuff:
Hamas security forces in the Gaza Strip have been instructed to uphold standards of manliness, Interior Minister Fathi Hammad said Tuesday.

Security services in Gaza should "keep an eye on those involved in reducing standards of manliness," Hammad said during a graduation speech for security officers, without providing further details.

The Interior Ministry and its security officials "have their own methods which will be used very openly," he added.
Hammad is referring to Hamas' practice since last year of arresting young men with "Western" pants and haircut styles that offend the Islamists.

I wonder if the people who are attending the PalFest literature festival in Gaza next week are nervous. This doesn't sound very "manly" to me:
Palestine Festival of Literature will host a cultural evening in one of Gaza's oldest houses. The evening will be a blend of music, Oud playing, Dabkah, in addition to poetry and prose readings by PalFest's guests and talented young writers.

In fact, last year Hamas did disrupt that same festival, forcing it to move to Cairo.

(h/t Adam L)

Elder gets results! The Economist partially corrects their story, while standing by it

Posted: 22 May 2013 03:00 AM PDT

The Economist finally corrected their online article where they had falsely written "So far this year, Israel's army has evicted almost 400 Palestinians from the West Bank and dismantled over 200 homes, the fastest rate for two years, according to the UN."

The article now says, somewhat more accurately, "So far this year Israel's army has evicted almost 400 Palestinian West Bankers from their homes in Area C, the fastest rate for two years, says the UN, and has dismantled over 200 residential and work-related structures."

The magazine wrote a response to some of you who complained, and this letter is masterful in its obfuscation. They do not admit that their original wording was incorrect:

You take particular issue with the following sentence: "So far this year, Israel's army has evicted almost 400 Palestinians from the West Bank and dismantled over 200 homes, the fastest rate for two years, according to the UN."

But the intended meaning was never in doubt from the context of the article as a whole, which is about housing in Area C. In that context, the phrase "from the West Bank" naturally refers not to the verb "evicted", but to the noun "Palestinians", which directly precedes it. In other words, the phrase "has evicted almost 400 Palestinians from the West Bank" means that "Palestinians living on the West Bank" were evicted from their homes, not from the West Bank altogether. And the next sentence clears up any ambiguity: "As a result, the European Union called on April 26th for an end to what it calls the "forced transfer" of Palestinians out of Area C."

You also object to the word "evicted", preferring "displaced". I cannot see a good reason for this. To be evicted means to be displaced against your will. For the Palestinians referred to in the article, this was plainly the case.

So that the meaning of this sentence cannot be misconstrued, deliberately or in isolation, we have amended the article online. The relevant sentence now reads:

"So far this year Israel's army has evicted almost 400 Palestinian West Bankers from their homes in Area C, the fastest rate for two years, says the UN, and has dismantled over 200 residential and work-related structures."
I will leave it to English majors to decide the merits of The Economist's "context" argument, and whether ordinary readers would interpret it as saying what they claim it says, and whether the only way anyone can see it otherwise is if they "misconstrue" it, and whether my own criticism was a deliberate misconstruing.

But if we are to talk about "context," then the question is why, out of all the sentences of that article, the Economist decided to tweet that particular one when publicizing the article online - without any context? The offending tweet is still online, retweeted some 465 times context-free by others:


Moreover, the Economist response twists my other point that the statistics did not come from a UN report, but from anti-Israel NGOs.

I wrote:

Sure enough, I found the document that the Economist based this on. It is not a UN document, but rather written by an alphabet soup of anti-Israel NGOs, hosted on the UN website

Here's what it says:
In 2013, 203 Palestinian structures have been demolished thus far, displacing 379 people, including 222 children, and otherwise affecting an additional 541 people's ability to earn an the income or access water and other basic services.
Nobody was evicted from the West Bank. 

The Economist replaced "displaced" with "evicted" and then added "from the West Bank." 

I have no idea whether the document is accurate to begin with - clearly, the unnamed reporter didn't make even a weak attempt to verify the facts with Israeli officials, something any real journalist, no matter how biased, would at least pretend to do. 
I gave links to the only document I could find at the UN site that mentioned the number of homes demolished by May, and that document says explicitly:

"As is" reference - not a United Nations document

Source: Association of International Development Agencies
1 May 2013

Aid agencies call for immediate end to demolitions and settlement expansion as Israel displaces Palestinians across the West Bank

ActionAid; Action Against Hunger (ACF); Agency for Technical Cooperation and Development (ACTED); American Friends Service Committee (AFSC); Diakonia; HelpAge International; Medical Aid for Palestinians (MAP UK); medico; Norwegian People's Aid (NPA); Norwegian Refugee Council (NRC); Polish Humanitarian Action (PAH); Premiere Urgence- Aide Medicale Internatonal (PU-AMI); Terres des Hommes (TdH- Italia); The Carter Center; The Lutheran World Federation (LWF); War Child Holland
(The exact same report was also published, with the same byline, at the UN's ReliefWeb website,and is not authored by the UN.)

Did the Economist find another document on the UN site that says how many Arabs were "evicted" and homes demolished? No:

You allege the article was drawn from a report that we mislabel as coming from the UN, which our correspondent then embroidered. This was not the case. It was based on meticulous on-the-ground research and conversations with Bedouin and Palestinian farmers, Jewish settlers and Israeli soldiers.

Our writer did also mention the UN report and an EU letter of protest in order to note that international bodies have recently made representations to the Israeli government on the same score.

It is thus incorrect, in any case, to say, as does the "Elder of Ziyon" blogpost, that the report (wrongly referred to as the basis of The Economist article) was "not a UN document but rather written by an alphabet soup of anti-Israel NGOs".

See:

http://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/47d4e277b48d9d3685256ddc00612265/ccec730492ad8a9785257afc004aefa1?OpenDocument

The linked UN article is indeed about home demolitions, but it was written in January 2013. Obviously it doesn't say how many homes were demolished by May.

But the Ecomonist's sentence, that they defend, says these statistics are "according to the UN."

If there is another UN-authored article that gives those statistics, I would happily issue a correction. But as it stands, the Economist is the party that has made an incorrect statement, not me.

Finally, The Economist defends their deliberate changing of the wording from the NGO report from "displaced" to "evicted":
You also object to the word "evicted", preferring "displaced". I cannot see a good reason for this. To be evicted means to be displaced against your will. For the Palestinians referred to in the article, this was plainly the case.

The writer made a conscious decision to change the wording to something more extreme than what the NGO report says. The NGO report uses a variant of the word "displaced" nine times, including the headline, and does not use the word "evicted" once - but the Economist decided to change it to a word that is more inflammatory, that - by the way - would also allow casual readers to "miscontrue" the meaning.. Strictly speaking, there is nothing wrong with the word itself, but that conscious choice to change the word indicates the bias by the writer, which was the main point I was trying to make, and this response by The Economist seems to buttress my argument more than to undermine it.

They end off by saying:

I trust that you can now see how this serious charge against our objectivity and integrity is based on a wilful misinterpretation. There was no "mistake". We do not "demonise" Israel. Your complaints, both regarding our intentions and the detail of our article, are unsubstantiated and completely unwarranted.

I trust that you can see that this is anything but the case here.

Despite the belated, condescending and misleading response, my main goal was to get The Economist to correct that offensive sentence that any casual reader would have interpreted as saying Israel evicted Palestinian Arabs from the West Bank - and that they did, kicking and screaming.

(h/t Stephen)

אין תגובות:

הוסף רשומת תגובה