Elder of Ziyon Daily News |
- Latest nutty Arab rumor: US ambassador says Jews are real owners of Egypt
- Hamas starts new campaign against immodest clothing, hairstyles
- Yes, MLK really did say the quote that anti-Zionism is anti-semitism
- Monday links
- Israel's Communist party admits it was behind social protests, Ha'aretz gloats
- Hamas fully supports Al Qaeda in Mali
- The Bantustans of New York (Infographic)
- Abbas says Israel wants to assassinate Saeb Erekat (updated)
Latest nutty Arab rumor: US ambassador says Jews are real owners of Egypt Posted: 21 Jan 2013 07:10 PM PST Arabic media is in an uproar over alleged statements from US ambassador to Egypt Anne Patterson. According to the story, Patterson told Ma'ariv that Jews are the real owners of Egypt, since they were expelled after they built the Pyramids and that DNA analysis showed that King Tut was of Jewish origin. Moreover, the ambassador is alleged to have said that "Israel will no longer be threatened by Arab barbarians who want to destroy it." Poverty and eventual bankruptcy in Egypt will push the Egyptians to famine, and then Jews will return again to the land of Egypt to enslave the Egyptians and feed them and save them from starvation and poverty, according to the bizarre rumored interview, which seems to be based on the biblical story of Joseph. Patterson is then supposed to have stressed that by the end of 2013 all of Egypt will be under the control of the Jews, perhaps through an all-out war with NATO, the US and Great Britain. One Egyptian politician has already called for Patterson to be expelled from the country because of these supposed statements. The US Embassy in Egypt issued a strong denial that any such interview took place, and of course, there is no such interview in Ma'ariv or anywhere else. They posted the denial on their Facebook page in Arabic and English: Statement on Falsehoods in the MediaArabic media is endlessly amusing. |
Hamas starts new campaign against immodest clothing, hairstyles Posted: 21 Jan 2013 02:45 PM PST Al Ahram and other media are reporting that Hamas has started a new campaign against "Western-style" clothing in Gaza, both for men and women. The campaign is titled "Upholding values and virtue." Hamas is especially cracking down on low-hanging pants that reveals undergarments, tight jeans, immodest abayas and "puffy" hairstyles. Preachers will emphasize the issue in their Friday sermons, and webpages and Facebook pages are being set up to teach Gazans how to dress in ways that do not reflect negatively on the sector that happens to be run by terrorists. |
Yes, MLK really did say the quote that anti-Zionism is anti-semitism Posted: 21 Jan 2013 01:00 PM PST It is always a pleasure to read the work of Martin Kramer, a real scholar, doing real research. This comes from last March: "When people criticize Zionists, they mean Jews. You're talking anti-Semitism!" —Martin Luther King, Jr. Aptly quoting Martin Luther King, Jr. is a common way to make a point or win an argument, and it's no surprise that his new memorial in Washington includes an "Inscription Wall" of quotes carved in stone. It's also no surprise that the quote about critics of Zionists didn't make the cut for inclusion in the memorial. Still, it's been put to use on many an occasion, most recently by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu last year, in his address to the Knesset on International Holocaust Remembrance Day. A few years back it even cropped up in a State Department report on antisemitism. So I was perplexed to see it categorized as "disputed" on the extensive page of King quotes at Wikiquote—for better or worse, the go-to place to verify quotes. Indeed, as of this writing, it's the only King quote so listed. The attempt to discredit the quote has been driven by politics. In particular, it's the work of Palestinians and their sympathizers, who resent the stigmatizing of anti-Zionism as a form of antisemitism. Just what sort of anti-Zionism crosses that fine line is a question beyond my scope here. But what of the quote itself? How was it first circulated? What is the evidence against it? And might some additional evidence resolve the question of its authenticity? King's words were first reported by Seymour Martin Lipset, at that time the George D. Markham Professor of Government and Sociology at Harvard, in an article he published in the magazine Encounter in December 1969—that is, in the year following King's assassination. Lipset: Shortly before he was assassinated, Martin Luther King, Jr. was in Boston on a fund-raising mission, and I had the good fortune to attend a dinner which was given for him in Cambridge. This was an experience which was at once fascinating and moving: one witnessed Dr. King in action in a way one never got to see in public. He wanted to find what the Negro students at Harvard and other parts of the Boston area were thinking about various issues, and he very subtly cross-examined them for well over an hour and a half. He asked questions, and said very little himself. One of the young men present happened to make some remark against the Zionists. Dr. King snapped at him and said, "Don't talk like that! When people criticize Zionists, they mean Jews. You're talking anti-Semitism!" For the next three-plus decades, no one challenged the credibility of this account. No wonder: Lipset, author of the classic Political Man (1960), was an eminent authority on American politics and society, who later became the only scholar ever to preside over both the American Sociological Association and the American Political Science Association. Who if not Lipset could be counted upon to report an event accurately? Nor was he quoting something said in confidence only to him or far back in time. Others were present at the same dinner, and Lipset wrote about it not long after the fact. He also told the anecdote in a magazine that must have had many subscribers in Cambridge, some of whom might have shared his "fascinating and moving" experience. The idea that he would have fabricated or falsified any aspect of this account would have seemed preposterous. That is, until almost four decades later, when two Palestinian-American activists suggested just that. Lipset's account, they wrote, "seems on its face… credible." There are still, however, a few reasons for casting doubt on the authenticity of this statement. According to the Harvard Crimson, "The Rev. Martin Luther King was last in Cambridge almost exactly a year ago—April 23, 1967″ ("While You Were Away" 4/8/68). If this is true, Dr. King could not have been in Cambridge in 1968. Lipset stated he was in the area for a "fund-raising mission," which would seem to imply a high profile visit. Also, an intensive inventory of publications by Stanford University's Martin Luther King Jr. Papers Project accounts for numerous speeches in 1968. None of them are for talks in Cambridge or Boston.--- When King was assassinated, the Crimson, Harvard's student newspaper, did write that he "was last in Cambridge almost exactly a year ago—April 23, 1967." That had been a very public visit, during which King and Dr. Benjamin Spock held a press conference to announce plans for a "Vietnam Summer." War supporters picketed King. But in actual fact, that wasn't King's last visit to Cambridge. In early October 1967, when news spread that King would be coming to Boston for the Belafonte concert, a junior member of Harvard's faculty wrote to King from Cambridge, to extend an invitation from the instructor and his wife: We would be anxious to be able to sit down and have a somewhat leisured meal with you, and perhaps with some other few people from this area whom you might like to meet. So much has happened in recent months that we are both quite without bearings, and are in need of some honest and tough and friendly dialogue…. So if you can find some time for dinner on Friday or lunch on Saturday, we are delighted to extend an invitation. If, however, your schedules do not permit, we of course will understand that. In any case, we look forward to seeing you at the Belafonte Concert and the party afterwards.Two days later, King's secretary, Dora McDonald, sent a reply accepting the invitation on King's behalf: "Dr. King asked me to say that he would be happy to have dinner with you." King would be arriving in Boston at 2:43 in the afternoon. "Accompanying Dr. King will be Rev. Andrew Young, Rev. Bernard Lee and I." Who was this member of the Harvard faculty? Martin Peretz. ...It was against this background that King came to dinner at the Peretz home at 20 Larchwood Drive, Cambridge, in the early evening of October 27, 1967. A few days later, King's aide, Andrew Young, thanked the couple for the delightful evening last Friday. It is almost too bad we had to go to the concert, but I think you will agree that the concert, too, proved enjoyable but I am also sure a couple of hours conversing with the group gathered in your home would have been more productive.In fact, the evening's significance would only become evident later, after King's death. For the dinner was attended by Peretz's senior Harvard colleague, Seymour Martin Lipset, and it was then and there that Lipset heard King rebuke a student who echoed the SNCC line on "Zionists": "When people criticize Zionists, they mean Jews. You're talking anti-Semitism!" Peretz would later assert that King "grasped the identity between anti-Israel politics and anti-semitic ranting." But it was Lipset who preserved King's words to that effect, by publishing them soon after they were spoken. (And just to run the contemporary record against memory, I wrote to Peretz, to ask whether the much-quoted exchange did take place at his Cambridge home on that evening almost 45 years ago. His answer: "Absolutely." ) It is worth reading the whole thing. And yet, even today, anti-Israel activists are casting doubt that the quote is accurate. For good reason: they know it is, and the idea that MLK was probably a Zionist drives them crazy. (This tweet was deleted after I responded, but her sarcastic response is still up.) More on MLK and Israel, between Kramer and Yaacov Lozowick, here. |
Posted: 21 Jan 2013 11:30 AM PST From Ian: Ayaan Hirsi Ali: Raised on Hatred "In recent decades Israeli and American administrations negotiated with unelected Arab despots, who played a double game. They honored the formal peace treaties by not conducting military attacks against Israel. But they condoned the Islamists' dissemination of hatred against Israel, Zionism and Jews. Morsi's Anti-Semitism Reveals More About Us Than Him "As I've long argued, anti-Semitism isn't just another form of bigotry. It is a method of explaining why the world is as it is; incendiary rhetoric against Jews, therefore, isn't just an afterthought, but the natural consequence of the genuinely held belief that our planet is in the grips of a Jewish conspiracy. One has to assume the Times would not have questioned whether the anti-Semitic outlooks of Hitler and Stalin were genuinely held, so why do so with Morsi?" Richard Humphreys: Surely Israel isn't the planet's worst human rights offender? "Israel is the only country in the Middle East that fully protects gay rights. Religious freedom. Free political dissent. Equal rights for women. By contrast, the Palestinian regime has somewhat different views on women and gays, as well as, shall we say, a rather old-fashioned attitude when it comes to the death penalty. US watchdog ranks Israel as region's only 'free' state "Israel is the Middle East's only "free" state, the US-based Freedom House wrote in its annual report last week, a ranking in stark contrast to claims by the country's critics – both domestic and international – who argue that the Jewish state's democratic values are steadily eroding "Israel remains the region's only free country," read the report, called Freedom in the World 2013, released just days before Israel goes to the polls." Melanie Phillips: Unless we become as single-minded as the fanatics, we are all hostages now "There is a seamless connection between jihadi movements abroad, the blind eyes turned to polygamy or the oppression of Muslim women in the UK, and debacles such as the failure to extradite Abu Qatada. PMW: PA TV Show Encourages Kids to Hijack Planes The EU and a host of NGOs are paying for a PA TV show that encourages, among other things, airline hijackings. PA TV visits family of terrorist prisoner Ibrahim Hamed, responsible for murder of 46 BBC's Danahar Tweets a "nothing to see – move along" on bullying of Orthodox youths "And the head of the BBC's Jerusalem Bureau makes his position on the story crystal clear, turning an abusive incident into a mere snowball fight and implying over-reaction on the part of the Israeli authorities." Arab Campaign in Europe Calls for 'Palestinian Spring' Arab group launches a new media campaign in Europe, calling on Arabs to establish more illegal outposts in Judea and Samaria. "A Palestinian Authority Arab group calling itself "the European initiative to remove the fence and the settlements" has launched a new media campaign in Europe, entitled "Palestine without a fence and with no settlements." Gaza 'Siege'? Arab Leaders Continue to Freely Visit Gaza's Hamas rulers constantly claim that the region is under an "Israeli siege", but continue to host leaders of Arab countries. "As well, according to a Sunday report in the PA's Wafa news agency, Malaysia's Prime Minister, Najib Razak, is scheduled to spend few hours in Gaza on Tuesday. Hezbollah's time is up In addition to the European Union proscribing Hezbollah, NATO must also enforce a buffer zone between Lebanon and Israel, writes Wahied Wahdat-Hagh "First, Europe must ban Lebanese Hezbollah as a terrorist organisation. Syria: when is a red line not a red line? "It is not the first time that the administration is widening the definition of its 'red line' concept. In the earlier stages of the conflict, the President declared that "a whole bunch of chemical weapons moving around" would lead to US action. He has now shifted his position to the point where the US will only get involved, if Assad uses chemical weapons on his own people. Prosecutor general investigates 'defamation of Islam' charges against Eissa "Prosecutor General Talat Abdallah will investigate a report accusing Al-Tahrir newspaper Editor-in-Chief Ibrahim Eissa of defaming Islam and ridiculing the Quran and Sharia. Ahmadinejad to Visit Cairo, Meet Morsi Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad will soon visit Cairo in order strengthen bilateral relations between the two countries. New report: Iranian Christians denied basic rights A new report has documented evidence of the persecution of Christians in Iran, including threats against life, as well as actual death sentences and imprisonment "The research revealed numerous reports of security officials threatening Christian detainees with execution on apostasy charges, and numerous cases of suspicious deaths involving Christian leaders whose investigations were so lacking in due diligence that government complicity in the killings or the cover-ups is strongly suggested. Police foil attack on Turkey church Turkish police have arrested 13 suspects accused of plotting an attack against members of a Protestant church and their pastor in a northwestern city, a local official said on Friday. Qatar Quietly Helping Yemenite Jews Reach Israel? "A Lebanese source says that a group of Jews from Yemen are on their way to Israel – via Qatar. Study shows olive trees may solve desertification Research finds tens of thousands of olive trees planted in Israel's arid areas environmentally beneficial Report: Israel to Buy Oil from South Sudan A report Sunday said that Israel had made a deal with South Sudan to purchase oil from the newest country in Africa |
Israel's Communist party admits it was behind social protests, Ha'aretz gloats Posted: 21 Jan 2013 09:45 AM PST From Ha'aretz: The social-protest movement was the secret strategic project of Hadash (Democratic Front for Peace and Equality). What was previously denied is denied no longer: Khenin's comrades were behind the almost-revolution that shook the country: They were the thinkers and organizers and responsible adults behind Daphni Leef and Stav Shafir and the tens of thousands they ostensibly led. But because communists are serious people, they never cashed in, never spilled the beans to the media and never reaped political capital from the subversive mass movement they spearheaded. Only now, as we sit in the old, charming party building on Ahad Ha'am Street in Tel Aviv, does one story follow hard on the heels of another.This is not sitting well with many of the protesters who now feel duped. However, the Ha'aretz writer, Ari Shavit, revels in his idolization of Israel's communists. Dov (Khenin) and Sharon (Shahaf) and Alon (Green) tell me about how they did what they did so that the people, whom the government is against, would rise up against it.Does this sound like a news story or a political endorsement for Hadash? Hadash is expected to get 4 seats in the next Knesset, which just goes to show how far left and unrepresentative of Israelis Ha'aretz now is. The second half of the article, about the far-left Meretz, eventually even does away with quotation marks - it quotes Zahava Gal-On in a way that makes it appear that Ha'aretz is talking, not Gal-On: Things will be terrible under the terrible government that Netanyahu will form after the election. But the new government will not last, and it will face potent opposition from a strong Meretz, which will fight the government fearlessly and ruthlessly. Next week, after Meretz doubles its strength, we will once more have a left wing that is returning to itself and restoring its belief in itself, and we will fight for our home.With Ha'aretz deleting the quotation marks, the line between Ha'aretz as a newspaper and as a far-left mouthpiece has finally been totally eradicated. (h/t Yoel) |
Hamas fully supports Al Qaeda in Mali Posted: 21 Jan 2013 08:00 AM PST The Al Qassam Brigades of Hamas has been tweeting messages of support for the Al Qaeda terrorists of Mali and against the French intervention. French war on Mali is just for stealing its natural resources especially Uranium and Gold (Video): ( A new #occupation) We feel pain about what is happening in #Mali#Gaza #Palestine #France #French #StopFrenchTerrorism #Terror #WarAgainstIslam #Hamas And they even tweeted the MEMRI video of the radical Islamists in London calling to take over the world. Plenty of people try to paint Hamas as being far more pragmatic and moderate than Al Qaeda. One reason, I believe, is because people simply do not want to believe that peace is impossible between Israel and its murderous neighbors. So they will cling to any hint of "moderation" and blow it out of proportion, and willfully ignore the overwhelming evidence of the truth: Hamas and Al Qaeda are virtually identical, in philosophy and in their goals of creating a worldwide Islamic caliphate.. Hamas even admits it: The only real difference is that Al Qaeda will attack civilian targets worldwide while Hamas confines its attacks to Israeli civilians. When Westerners say that they want to engage Hamas, it is just as ridiculous as saying you want to negotiate with Al Qaeda. When Fatah says that they want to unify with Hamas, they also know very well who they are making deals with - and it doesn't bother them in the least. |
The Bantustans of New York (Infographic) Posted: 21 Jan 2013 05:30 AM PST |
Abbas says Israel wants to assassinate Saeb Erekat (updated) Posted: 21 Jan 2013 03:15 AM PST Al Medayeen will broadcast a wide-ranging interview with Mahmoud Abbas this Friday, and part of what he says is being teased ahead of time. Abbas said, "I challenge anyone to deny the relationship between Zionism and Nazism before World War II." This is, of course, a sickening implication. There were contacts before World War II as Zionists tried to save Jews from Germany; for example, the Ha'avara Agreement. Abbas is however trying to spin it as if Zionists and Nazis were cooperating in genocide, which puts him beneath contempt. Abbas also says that "Palestine" requested to save 150,000 Palestinian Arab refugees from Syria, and Israel agreed to it. Unless something has changed, Abbas had rejected Israel's conditions, so the details will be interesting. Furthermore, Abbas charged that Israel wanted to get rid of Saeb Erekat, chief negotiator for the PLO, saying they wanted to assassinate him like they did to Arafat. Mahmoud Abbas seems to be turning paranoid in his old age. UPDATE: Yoel writes: According to Maariv Abbas also said that he will write 70 books that prove the ties between the Zionist movement and the Nazis before WWII. He challenges any Jew to prove him wrong. Abbas also hinted 3 times that there are people who want to kill him and get rid of him, not Erekat. |
You are subscribed to email updates from Elder of Ziyon To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
Google Inc., 20 West Kinzie, Chicago IL USA 60610 |
אין תגובות:
הוסף רשומת תגובה