| Hilarious boycott of Israeli goods by tiny cafe in Olympia Posted: 06 Jun 2012 07:34 PM PDT BDS has another victory! We, The Flaming Eggplant Cafe, have decided to join the call from Palestinian civil society to boycott Israeli products. "These non-violent punitive measures should be maintained until Israel meets its obligation to recognize the Palestinian people's inalienable right to self-determination and fully complies with the precepts of international law by:
- Ending its occupation and colonization of all Arab lands and dismantling the Wall;
- Recognizing the fundamental rights of the Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel to full equality; and
- Respecting, protecting and promoting the rights of Palestinian refugees to return to their homes and properties as stipulated in UN resolution 194." (from the Palestinian Civil Society call for BDS)
This comes from the Olympia BDS webpage, but curiously enough not from the Flaming Eggplant webpage. In fact, there is nothing about it on their Facebook page or Twitter account as of this writing, either. But it is probably true. The cafe also boycotts Nestle, Monsanto and Coca Cola. Only one problem: According to their menu and their list of suppliers, they never sold Israeli products anyway. In fact, they deliberately choose products from local producers whenever they can. Their hummus is made in-house. Saying that you, as a business, are banning products that you never sold is not exactly a sacrifice. [NEWSFLASH: This webpage will no longer use any Iranian components! Praise me!] How about traditional Middle Eastern foods? Where does the Flaming Eggplant get them from? All the food that we buy from our distributors is organic. We work with some small producers on the west coast through our distributors including Jerusalem House, a company started by immigrants from the Middle East that makes our tahini... The Jerusalem House is an Oregon health food distributor. It has a vague Middle East connection. Sounds like it is perfect for the Flaming Eggplant's ethical standards. Except that a couple of weeks ago there was one small problem... A local food company has recalled all varieties of its humus products over concerns about potential contamination.
Jerusalem House issued the recall on May 17, and products have been pulled from the shelves at area stores.
The products were sold at all Market of Choice locations in Oregon; Sundance Natural Foods, Friendly Street Market and Capella in Eugene; and at First Alternative Natural Foods Co-op in Corvallis.
The products recalled include hummus, black bean hummus, baba ghanouj, grape leaves, salsa de jardin and tahini packaged under the Jerusalem House label and Original Tahini packaged under the Earth Gourmet Foods label.
An announcement from the state Agriculture Department said the products could contain a chemical contaminant. The recall notice does not identify the potential contaminant but said no illnesses have been reported in connection with the problem.
The announcement said the recall was initiated "in an abundance of caution." Oh, it gets better: Two days before the recall, on May 15, Eugene police served a search warrant at a west Eugene home police said served as a commercial food sales operation for Jerusalem House.
Roy Simon Oueis, 50, was arrested on charges of possession of methamphetamine, delivery of methamphetamine within 1,000 feet of a school, felon in possession of a weapon and first-degree theft.
Oueis' business profile on the LinkedIn website lists him as manager of Jerusalem House.
Oueis remained in custody Sunday.
 | | "Jerusalem House" drug den according to Google Maps | The report said the police investigation turned up potential violations of building and health codes at 2425 W. 18th Ave., the location where the search warrant was served. [And the official address of Jerusalem House - EoZ]
City code inspectors and state agriculture inspectors were called to investigate.
The recall notice did not indicate a link between the arrest and the recall. But production of Jerusalem House products has been suspended while the investigation continues. Oueis, the owner of Jerusalem House, was arrested "after an investigation revealed that he routinely traded methamphetamine for stolen property, police said. " The ethical owner of the ethical health food company was also arrested in 2007 for possession of a firearm and, again, methamphetamines. This is where The Flaming Eggplant prefers to procure its food from. But give Oueis a break - he was born in Lebanon, so that makes him ipso facto a moral man and his company an ethical business. Will The Flaming Eggplant, arbiters of what is good and right, choose to boycott The Jerusalem House - assuming it ever resumes business operations? Will they be writing any articles for Olympia BDS about the evils of methamphetamines, selling drugs and possession of a weapon? Are they thinking that perhaps they wouldn't have lost their supplier of tahini if they had chosen an Israeli brand? I love BDS, really I do. 
|
| Malaysia clerics cool sales of Portugal soccer jerseys Posted: 06 Jun 2012 03:00 PM PDT From Bikya Masr: The small street seller had all the European club jerseys ready for sale on Saturday evening, as passersby wanted to grab their favorite international shirt ahead of this month's Euro 2012. But for Portugal fans, the jersey was nowhere to be found.
"We are not allowed to sell the jersey because it shows a cross," the shopkeeper told Bikyamasr.com. "I still love Portugal and will be rooting for them, but we are an Islamic country and don't want to get people angry," he added.
While it is not officially banned in the country, a number of Islamic clerics have voiced their concern over the jersey, which has a large cross on the front, highlighting Portugal's Catholic faith. But in Malaysia, symbols often find themselves under attack by the country's virulent Muslim clerics.
Portugal is not the only jersey to be pulled from the shelves. Brazil, which also boasts a large cross, has been barred by clerics. Manchester United, the world's most popular club team, has also sparked the ire of clerics in the Southeast Asian country over its nickname, the Red Devils.
Despite the Old Trafford side having an estimated 81 million followers in Asia, one senior cleric said: "You are only promoting the devil."
"This is very dangerous. As a Muslim we should not worship the symbols of other religions or the devils," another added, in a Forbes report.
"It will erode our belief in Islam. There is no reason why we as Muslims should wear such jerseys, either for sports or fashion reasons." 
|
| A little context on "Israeli racism" Posted: 06 Jun 2012 01:20 PM PDT While racism must always be condemned, the next time you read an article about how Israelis are supposedly racist for mistreating illegal African immigrants flooding the country, keep in mind how Egyptians treat them. From CNN, last November: "I wanted to build a good future for my family, but I failed," a weak Issam Abdallah Mohammed said in a videotaped statement.
The refugee from the Darfur region of Sudan was trying to illegally cross the border from Egypt to Israel when he was discovered and shot by Egyptian border guards.
Less than an hour after taping the statement, Issam was dead, succumbing to the wounds inflicted by the gunshots.
Every year, thousands of refugees, mostly from Eritrea, Ethiopia and Sudan, attempt the dangerous journey from their war-torn countries to Israel in search of economic prosperity and stability.
Very few make it, and the results of the failed migration can be seen in the morgue of the central hospital in the Egyptian port town of El Arish.
On any given day, the morgue will be packed with the bodies of African refugees who died trying to make it to Israel.
Hamdy Al-Azazy spent the past seven years helping the refugees. Many are enslaved and tortured and the women raped by the Bedouin tribes of the Sinai if they are unable to come up with large sums of money the Bedouin try to extort from them and their families, to smuggle the refugees across the border into Israel. As a result, many remain imprisoned in camps on the Sinai Peninsula.
"They are chained and kept in camps in the open with no bathrooms and little water and food and treated worse than animals," Al-Azazy said.
"Some of them are taken to Libya, but 80% of them are smuggled to Israel. Those who escape are shot by the Bedouins, and others who make it to the border are sometimes shot by the Egyptian authorities and transferred to hospitals before spending a year in different prisons in Sinai and deported back home."
The CNN crew found two victims in the hospital in El Arish, handcuffed to their beds and awaiting their transfer to an Egyptian detention center and eventual deportation.
One of them, Mahary Taklay Abraham of Eritrea, says he hit his head falling off a rock while trying to cross the border and was caught by Egyptian border guards. But before making it to the border, Mahary says, he spent about two months with the Bedouins.
"They beat and tortured me continuously and demanded money from my family," Mahary said.
Al-Azazy says this is a common scheme. The refugees will pay Bedouin tribes in the border area between Sudan and Egypt around $2,000 to be smuggled out. The smugglers then sell the refugees to the Sinai Bedouin, who blackmail the refugees and their families back home.
Ibrahim Yehia of Eritrea says he fell prey to the Bedouin.
"When we arrived to Sinai, the Bedouins tied me up with metal chains in the desert. They tortured us. Many of us died," he said, displaying his wounds, including scars that he says came from electroshock torture.
"They wanted me to pay $12,000 and forced us to call our families to transfer the money. My family sold all their lands and even their donkey to collect the money. They transferred $6,000 to the Bedouins."
After his family paid, Yehia says, the Bedouin finally let him go.
"I spent three months tied up in the camp close to the Israeli border. After I paid, the Bedouins drove me to the border crossing and set me free. I was then shot by plainclothes men close to the wired fence at the Israeli-Egyptian border. The military took me to the hospital."
Some of the refugees are forced into slave labor, often working marijuana fields that flourish all over Northern Sinai, Hamdy Al-Azazy says. Refugees who made it across the border into Israel have told harrowing accounts of rape, torture and slave labor.
Women are especially vulnerable. CNN spoke to one victim who made it to Israel and spoke on condition of anonymity. She said she was raped almost daily on a journey that took several months to get to Tel Aviv.
"Every night, they took me separately, and they did whatever they wanted to my body," the Eritrean said.
Al-Azazy hears stories like this all the time. "The women and men are kept in open areas. These Bedouins don't have any morals or conscience. One girl told me that three Bedouins had raped 14 girls in one night," he said. How many articles have you read in 2012 about Egyptian murder, rape and enslavement of African migrants? 
|
| Ian's links including anti-Israel protest in Australia Posted: 06 Jun 2012 12:00 PM PDT A developing story in Australia, an effigy of Victorian State Premier Baillieu was burnt by anti-Israel protesters outside a gala dinner to celebrate the 64th anniversary of the creation of Israel, the Israeli Ambassador was also attending. Later: Function Sizzles, Demo Fizzles "Around forty demonstrators were part of a group which burned an effigy of Victorian premier Ted Baillieu outside Melbourne's Hotel Windsor in which Victorians were celebrating Israel's 64th birthday.
The demonstration was staged in an attempt to disrupt the Yom Ha'azmaut party inside at which more than 400 members of the community heard speeches from from the Victorian premier and Daniel Andrews the Leader of the Opposition" Jewish News coverage (Video inc clips of speeches)- Flames of protest fail to mar spirits Chanting "from the river to the sea" (video)- Protest outside Zionist Council of Victoria dinner with Premier Ted Baillieu They appear to amazed at this thing called fire (video)- Free Palestine demo Melbourne 5 June 2012 As always give them thumbs down in YT.
Rabbi Arnold J. Wolf, the Socialist, anti-Israel Rabbi Who Taught Obama What He 'Knows' About Judaism "For example, along with radical MIT professor Noam Chomsky, Rabbi Wolf helped found the Committee on New Alternatives in the Middle East (CONAME) a philosophical grandparent to today's faux pro-Israel group J Street. .....An investigation by the Near East Report revealed that CONAME's signature appeared on telegrams urging Congress to send no arms to Israel during the 1973 Yom Kippur War, when Israel was attacked by Syria and Egypt on the holiest day in the Jewish calendar." MEMRI Dr. Subhi Al-Yaziji, Dean of Koranic Studies at the Islamic University of Gaza: We Hope to Conquer Andalusia and the Vatican Munich Olympics terror victims deserve a minute of our time The Real Purpose of Boycotts What goes unmentioned is that the boycott called for by the Palestinian Authority is a violation of the April 29, 1994 Paris Agreement between Israel and the PLO which expresses "respect for each other's economic interests," and recognizes "the need to create a better economic environment for their peoples and individuals." Palestinians Blackmail Washington over True Refugee Numbers Palestinians: Refugees forever? UNRWA was created to punish Israel Saudis block blog for hosting religious police mall video! How we got censored by the Saudis Fox map of ME only shows Gaza? Fox News Omits Israel Barbara Walters apologises over links to Syrian aide of Bashar al-Assad The same aide was behind the Vogue's whitewash. Vogue Defends Syrian Glow Job Walters and Wintour part of Assad's PR spin machine and big Obama supporters. IDF Video Learn How To Defend Yourself: Krav Maga 101 
|
| Gaza power plant shuts down again, and no one can explain why Posted: 06 Jun 2012 10:45 AM PDT From AFP: Gaza's sole power station shut down again on Wednesday after running out of fuel, a source at the plant told AFP, as the territory's energy crisis deepened.
"The electricity plant has stopped work because of a lack of fuel," the source said.
The plant has stopped working several times this year as the Gaza Strip lives through its worst-ever energy crisis which has been brought on by a drop in fuel supplies from neighbouring Egypt.
On Wednesday, a delivery of 30 million litres of Qatari fuel was to have entered the Hamas-run Gaza Strip from Egypt, after being transported through Egypt's Al-Awja crossing into southern Israel, then into Gaza through the Kerem Shalom crossing.
But on Wednesday afternoon, Raed Futuh, an official at Kerem Shalom said the delivery had been delayed for the fourth time in three weeks, citing "technical issues."
Last month, Israel gave the green light for the fuel to be transferred through its territory after receiving a request from the Egyptians, an Israeli security official said. This doesn't add up. Israel continues to supply, every day, roughly the same amount of fuel it has supplied since April when the PA agreed to pay for Israel to send fuel through Kerem Shalom. Nothing has changed. Yesterday over 270,000 liters were sent through. If the PA would pay more, Israel would supply more. And Gaza's power plant, while not at close to full capacity, has been running fine since then with only a few unexplained glitches. Since Hamas has a history of manipulating supplies of vital goods to Gaza in order to score political points, it seems plausible that Hamas is trying to pressure Egypt to allow the Qatari fuel to get to the sector sooner rather than later. (I'm cynical enough to wonder if Egypt is siphoning off some of that fuel to stave off its own impending fuel crisis.) 
|
| Arab political cartoons on the eve of war, 1967 Posted: 06 Jun 2012 09:00 AM PDT
 | | "The neck of the bottle - the Straits of Tiran" Rose al Youssef, Egypt, May 29, 1967 |
 | | "The Zionist to Hell," Syrian army newspaper, May 30, 1967 |  | The mouths of the guns of eight Arab countries: Sudan, Algeria, United Arab Republic, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon. Al Jarida , Beirut, May 31, 1967
|  | Armored forces of Egypt, Syria, Jordan and Lebanon. Al Hayat, Beirut, May 31, 1967
 | | The clubs fall on the head of Israel: Israel asks: Where can I run? Al Goumhourya , Baghdad, June 6, 1967 | 
"Holy war" Al Goumhourya, Cairo, June 8, 1967
|  | | "Using the Star of David," Al Manar , Baghdad, June 8, 1967 |  | | "The Zionists into the sea," Al-Arabiya Al-Jamahir , Baghdad, June 8, 1967 |  | | "The barricades of Tel Aviv," Al-Jundi Al Arabi , Damascus, June 6, 1967 |  | | Nasser kicking the Jew (Israel) into the sea, with the armies of Lebanon, Syria and Iraq supporting him. Al-Farida, Lebanon | Most images from here, last one from here. 
|
| Amnesty's credibility problem (YNet) plus a new example of AI bias Posted: 06 Jun 2012 07:30 AM PDT An op-ed by Gidon Shaviv: What do you get when you combine a radical activist who volunteers as a human shield for terrorists with a former Palestinian Authority spokesman? The Israel research department for Amnesty International.
"Impartiality" is a core value of Amnesty's statute. Further, Amnesty's editorial guidelines state, "Media content produced by Amnesty International should be fair and objective."
These claims of "impartiality" and "objectivity" are the foundation of Amnesty's reputation as one of the leading promoters of human rights. In Israel's case, however, Amnesty ignores its own values and instead allows people with clearly biased agendas to produce its reports. This is apparent in Amnesty's upcoming report on Israel's use of administrative detention, to be released on June 6. Amnesty lists two workers with clear conflicts of interests - Deborah Hyams and Saleh Hijazi - as the report's media contacts.
Hyams joined Amnesty in 2010, after a long record of pro-Palestinian activism. In 2001 she volunteered as a "human shield" in Beit Jala, near Bethlehem, to deter Israeli military responses to recurrent gunfire and mortar attacks targeting Jewish civilians in Jerusalem. In a 2002 Washington Jewish Week article, "Hyams said that while she does not condone suicide bombings, she personally believes they 'are in response to the occupation.'" In another instance she defended the use of violence, stating "occupation is violence… and the consequence of this action must result in violence." This background precludes any reader of Amnesty's report from accepting it at face value.
As with the case of Hyams, if Amnesty wants to maintain impartiality, it should disqualify Saleh Hijazi from working on Israeli issues. Hijazi, a Palestinian born in Jerusalem and raised in Ramallah, has a clear lack of objectivity in this regard. In 2005, he worked as a Public Relations officer for the Office of the Ministry of Planning in Ramallah and in 2007 he was listed as contact for the NGO "Another Voice" – under the group's signature "Resist! Boycott! We Are Intifada!"
Hijazi has a "special" conflict of interest with regards to administrative detention in particular. On March 9, 2011, while as a researcher for Human Rights Watch, he spoke at a UN conference where he described how his father was supposedly arrested by the Israeli authorities "when the Israeli military could not find an activist neighbor." How can Hijazi be impartial when he is simultaneously claiming to be a victim of the very same country on which he is reporting?
...When human rights organizations are co-opted by people with a specific political agenda, they are incapable of fulfilling their mandates. Amnesty's choice to staff its Israel section with clearly biased researchers has made it tragically irrelevant for the championing of human rights in the region as a whole. Those who value human rights should be the most outspoken against the political hijacking of one of the world's most powerful NGOs. I've documented Amnesty's anti-Israel bias many times. For starters: Amnesty UK's duplicity, bias and false accusations against Israel Sky News bias and Amnesty hypocrisy Amnesty implies the ICC is a Zionist tool Amnesty officially calls Turkel report a "whitewash" - with no proof (More details here.) Amnesty blames Israel for PalArab abuse of women Amnesty International: When even-handedness is stupid Amnesty supports a confessed Hezbollah spy Amnesty's hateful bedfellows JCPA just published a paper showing how HRW and Amnesty treat targeted killings (TKs) differently when done by Israel and when done by every other Western state. And once again, the bias of human rights groups against Israel is clear (although HRW's is, as usual, much worse): In total, the author has identified 14 AI documents denouncing the Israeli TK policy.
AI has released precisely the same number of reports regarding Western TKs. In other words, AI has released the same number of reports criticizing a single country's policy, as the number it has released concerning the same policy employed by several countries – the U.S. and its allies – in numerous theaters since 9/11 (including Iraq, Afghanistan, Somalia, Syria, Yemen and Pakistan). Although the Israeli TK policy and the Western TK policy have been implemented for approximately the same period of time, the Western TK policy is used far more frequently, in at least five countries, with a far greater incidence of collateral damage. In contrast, the Israeli TK policy is used only in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank with a very low rate of collateral damage. Therefore, the number of AI's critical reports targeting Israel appears unbalanced, verging on biased – a clear violation of the principles to which AI is supposedly committed.
AI's material is characterized, moreover, by inaccurate and disparate terminology. In every document released by AI which mentions Israeli TKs, Israeli TK policy was branded as categorically "unlawful" and Israeli TKs were consistently referred to as "assassinations" and/or "liquidations." As discussed in detail in Part II, Section B, supra, killing militants during an armed conflict cannot, under the laws of war, be considered "assassination," or "liquidation," nor be "unlawful." Moreover, at the time that AI made these statements there was no consensus that Israeli TKs – or Western TKs, for that matter – were unlawful. In fact quite the opposite is true....
Meanwhile, AI has never used this terminology, which in and of itself implies illegality and culpability, concerning Western TKs. AI has never clearly and irrevocably condemned Western TKs, choosing instead to neutrally refer to them as "air raids,""air strikes,"220 and "missile strikes."In fact, AI has rarely, if ever, expressed clear reservations regarding the Western TK policy – other than perhaps when referring to the TK in Yemen in 2002. 
|
| Morning snippets Posted: 06 Jun 2012 06:00 AM PDT Why has Queen Elizabeth II never visited Israel? [A]midst all the accolades, state dinners, and thousands of "Jubilee beacons" being lit around the world, one aspect of the Queen's resume stands out for its inexplicable absence: In six decades of reign she has made hundreds of royal visits to 129 different countries, though never once been to Israel.
No comparable nation has been even remotely ignored in this way. There are only two incidents of British royal family visiting Israel over the past 64 years – Prince Philip at a ceremony honoring his mother, and Prince Charles attending the funeral of Yitzhak Rabin. Yet both times the British were careful to emphasize that these were private, non-official visits.
...Surely Israel doesn't need the Queen for recognition or legitimization. However, upon this occasion of her diamond jubilee, what a propitious time for Queen Elizabeth to make a strong statement of support by visiting the Jewish State! This would go a long way to dispel the lingering cloud of delegitimization. It would surely be another jewel in the Queen's glorious crown. Donald Rumsfeld thinks that the Obama administration very possibly would leak any Israeli plans to attack Iran. ( Breitbart) CAMERA notes how the NYT allowed a lie to be published in an anti-Israel op-ed: In the racist state of California, there are over 50 laws on the books that discriminate against Latino citizens.
Actually, that's a lie. But it is a lie that the New York Times, according to editors, would have no problem publishing.
We know this because the newspaper recently published an Op-Ed containing the outlandish claim that Israel has "over 35 laws" that "discriminate against Palestinians who are Israeli citizens." This falsehood, the latest version of a shopworn anti-Israel canard, was cleared for publication by fact checkers despite journalism's ethical guidelines calling for opinion pieces to be held to the same standards of accuracy as news stories.
CAMERA has asked editors to provide substantiation for the allegation, which appeared in a May 23 Op-Ed by Yousef Munayyer entitled "Not All Israeli Citizens Are Equal."
They have yet to provide a credible source. And it seems clear that this is because no such source exists.
Even the hyperlink from the passage about "35 laws" in the online version of the column leads to a web page that fails to substantiate, and in fact contradicts, Munayyer's claim. That reference discusses "bills" and "legislation submitted to the Knesset" as well as laws, which are said to discriminate against minorities including "refugees and migrant workers." In other words, it includesproposed laws that if passed would supposedly discriminate against non-citizens (as laws sometimes do — see the right to vote).
But even the website Munayyer and the Times link to fails to name the supposed 35 laws and bills. Fortunately (or perhaps unfortunately is the better word), we already know what such a list would look like. Cyberspace is littered with anti-Israel web pages that wildly twist and contort to present evenhanded and innocuous laws as discriminating against Arab citizens. The BBC on how some Germans are thinking of re-evaluating their policy towards Israel. Melanie Phillips on "A Jewish Pathology": The part played by these Jews in the global bullying of Israel, and the tacit or explicit support they are thus lending to those whose aim is the extermination of the Jewish state, cannot be overstated. For those in the wider world who want Israel destroyed not only use the bogus arguments of these Jewish Israel-bashers but also use their Jewishness as a human shield, to insulate themselves against the charge of Jew-hatred.
How can there be anything bigoted about these arguments, they say, if Jews and Israelis are themselves using them? Very easily, actually; throughout the long centuries of Jewish persecution, the terrible fact is that Jews themselves have always been prominent in such murderous campaigns. The Judeophobic malice of today's left, indeed, which can be traced back to the French Revolution, was supplied with rocket fuel by Karl Marx whose own Jewish ancestry managed to morph into virulent hatred of Judaism and the Jewish people. (h/t John W., Yerushalimey) 
|
| Debunking the "Bride is beautiful, but she is married to another man" myth Posted: 06 Jun 2012 02:35 AM PDT In the introduction to his influential 2001 book "The Iron Wall: Israel and the Arab World," Avi Shlaim writes: The book was not only a sensation, but the entire introduction with this prologue was published in the New York Times website. This anecdote spread like wildfire in the anti-Zionist world. It was quoted widely in scholarly journals and books and in fact became the basis for the title of a book by Ghada Karmi called "Married to Another Man" where she argues that Israel must not exist as a Jewish state. And no wonder. Avi Shlaim is an acclaimed revisionist historian and this myth that Jews muscled into Israel and stole the land away from the Arabs is all the more compelling when it appears that they did it knowingly, in stark terms of stealing a bride away from a loving husband. However, Shai Afsai in the latest Shofar journal proves that this story is a myth. He tracks down the truth starting with Karmi: Where did Karmi get this story from? For some time, she did not respond to e-mails requesting information on her source, but in 2010 she furnished this reply: "The story's origins has caused me problems. I got the citation from Avi Shlaim at Oxford, who gave me a reference for it, which turned out not to be correct. I then searched hard for the source and have come up with a blank. I fear it might be apocryphal, much as I had not wanted that. Sorry!" She later added that Shlaim told her "the story had appeared in a book by Muhammad Hassanein Heikal. But it was not there." By then, she had already been repeating various versions of it for several years, in essays, lectures, interviews, and an entire book titled after the story. Her scholarly paradigm assumed the immorality of Zionism, and she found support for her essential position in a fabrication. Shlaim, as Afsai notes, has lots of footnotes in his book - but none for this story: As with Karmi and Pagden, Shlaim provides no source for the "married to another man" story he tells, despite there being twenty-one pages of notes at the back of The Iron Wall. Responding to a question about his source, Shlaim wrote in a 2009 e-mail that it was Mohamed Heikal's Secret Channels (1996). This book is listed in Shlaim's bibliography, along with two other works by Heikal, a prominent Egyptian journalist, author, and commentator, who was the editor-in-chief of Al-Ahram for many years, as well as an adviser to (and mouthpiece of) Egypt's President Nasser. In Secret Channels, Heikal writes:
Herzl convened the first World Zionist Congress, which brought together Jewish representatives from many countries. It was held in Basel, Switzerland on 23 August 1897 and is regarded by Jews as a landmark in the creation of the state of Israel. The World Zionist Congress was created with the aim of establishing "a home for the Jewish people in Palestine secured under public law." After the Basel conference the rabbis of Vienna decided to see for themselves what Herzl was talking about, and sent two representatives to Palestine. A cable sent by the two rabbis during their visit became famous: "The bride is beautiful, but she is married to another man." It was a message Zionists did not wish to hear, and the inconvenient husband was never acknowledged.
As with Karmi, Pagden, and Shlaim's accounts, no source for the Viennese expedition and its "famous" cable is provided in Heikal's Secret Channels. In fact, the book has no endnotes at all, nor does it contain a bibliography, which raises the question of how Shlaim could consider Secret Channels an adequate source for the veracity of the "married to another man" story. In his preface to The Iron Wall, he writes of his method:
Like the British historian E. H. Carr, I believe that the main task of the historian is not to record but to evaluate.
Carr also described the writing of history as a perpetual dialogue between the historian and his sources. A word about the sources used in the writing of this book might therefore be of some interest . . . wherever possible I have preferred to rely on primary sources, whether in English, French, Hebrew, or Arabic."62
Somehow, the "married to another man" story Shlaim found in Heikal's book warranted no evaluation, needed no dialogue between the historian and his source, and did not require seeking out a primary source for it in any language. The story is, in other words, a lie. Yet that lie persists. For example, in a recent interview with David Wilder, Egyptian/Belgian journalist Khaled Diab quotes it twice to make the point that Jews knew that the land belonged to Arabs. This is one of those stories that the anti-Zionist world finds "too good to check." The "rabbis" aren't named, no sources are cited, and it is just regarded as truth because it is what the anti-Israel crowd desperately wants to believe, so they have elevated the story to mythic status. Will we be seeing any corrections from the many "Middle East scholars" like Anthony Pagden, Ghada Karmi and Avi Shlaim who quote a lie without checking? (h/t Diana Muir Applebaum and Challah Hu Akbar for research) 
|
אין תגובות:
הוסף רשומת תגובה